Close

March 22, 2018

Which D&D 5e Book Should You Buy?

News and Reviews Featured Image

The Dungeons and Dragons 5e core books, the Player’s Handbook, the Monster Manual, and the Dungeon Masters Guide have been out for almost 4 years now. Since the release of 5e, Wizards of the Coast has released 16 total books with 2 more on the way this year. That’s a lot of books. They all cost about $30-$60 each. That’s expensive for a new player or DM! So, what D&D 5e book should I buy? Are there any “must-have” book(s) in order to play?

The links to the books in this post all contain my amazon affiliate ID. What this means is that at no charge to you I get a kickback should you purchase an item using a link in this post. This money will be used to help offset the fees for running Dungeon Solvers as well as reinvesting any extra money back into the site to create better content! Thank you!

The Problem

I’m going to tackle this problem by suggesting that there is a certain order in which I believe these books are best to be purchased in. In this post, I have separated the books into 5 Tiers. Start with Tier 1 and purchase the books that interest you. From there move down to the next section the next time you want to buy a new book.

I’ve personally used this system to recommend books to my friends and it has worked out well for veteran players, new players, dungeon masters, and everyone in-between!

Tier 1 – Must Have

There is only a single D&D 5e book in the “Must Have” tier. This book will provide all the information needed to DM or play in a D&D 5e campaign.

DnD 5e Players Handbook

The 5e Player’s Handbook is hands-down the tier 1 book of D&D 5e. Art by WotC.

Player’s Handbook 

The Player’s Handbook contains all of the basic rules, character options, equipment, and spells in the game. As a player or a full-time DM this is an absolute staple. Obviously for players having access to the rules, classes, feats, equipment, spells, races, and backgrounds makes this book an obvious choice.

A DM could absolutely run a game using only the Player’s Handbook and some monster stat blocks they found on the internet. This book is a reference for everyone at the table. Trust me, regardless of your role at the table you will look through this book at least a couple of times a session. Buy this book before you purchase any other book in the collection.

Tier 2 – Cornerstones

The “Cornerstones” tier includes two books. I do not deem both of these books necessary for both DMs and Players to own. However, they are the books I frequently use as both a DM and a player.

Monster Manual

As a DM the Monster Manual is basically your best friend. This holds a few hundred monsters for you to throw at your unsuspecting adventurers. I constantly have this book open and bookmarked whenever I am running a session. The variety of monsters is particularly good. I have been able to regularly surprise my five players with monsters they have never encountered in over 3 years of playing D&D 5e.

As a player this book is a pass. If you have no intentions of ever DMing I would not recommend picking this book up. That being said you should give DMing a try anyways, you may like it more than you’d think!

d&d 5e book, Xanathar's Guide to Everything

The new Fighter archetypes in XGtE. Art by WotC.

Xanathar’s Guide to Everything

Xanathar’s Guide to Everything is by far my favorite D&D 5e book. Each class got new character archetypes. Tons of new spells and feats were added. It also added so many awesome tables and tools for DMs. There are tables that explain how to distribute magical items to players, all the official Druid wild shape forms, and more.

Seriously, XGtE is practically a second Player’s Handbook with how much content it holds. It is absolutely worth the money as a player and has a ton of great tools for DMs. Both camps would benefit by adding XGtE to their collection.

Tier 3 – Expansions

The “Expansions” books are great books. They expand the content of the game and fill in some areas the books of the first 2 tiers only touch upon. They require at least the Player’s Handbook and/or the Monster manual in order to use them to their fullest potential.

Volo’s Guide to Monsters

I had originally placed Volo’s Guide to Monsters in Tier 2. However, after some thought, I decided against that. It has a lot of content such as new character races, monster lore, and plenty of new monsters for DMs to use. A lot of these new creatures include new versions of creatures in the MM such as the Flind which is a high CR gnoll. I have used many of the creatures in my games. There are a lot of more unique takes on creatures in VGtM and they can make for a fun twist on a creature your players are accustomed to.

The player races are very unique and fun, but that’s all that is in there for players unfortunately. That being said, there are quite a few unique races and it adds quite a few monstrous races such as goblins and kenku.

VGtM is an excellent D&D 5e book for DMs, but one I would put lower on my list if I were a full-time player.

Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes

I’m pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed all the lore. Art by WotC.

Mordenkainen’s Tome of Foes

The structure of Mordenkainen’s Tome of Foes is pretty similar to VGtM. It contains a lot of interesting lore focused around the blood war as well as many of the races in the PHB. There is also plenty of lore for the creatures that partook in the blood war such as iconic demons and devils. There are chapters full of lore for tieflings, gith, dwarves, gnomes, and halflings as well.

For players, the book includes a brand-new race, the gith, as well as subraces for elves and tiefling. In addition to these races and subraces duergar and deep gnomes have also been reprinted for those of you that have not purchased the Sword Coast Adventurer’s Guide.

Like VGtM this book is excellent for DMs as it contains over 100 statblocks for brand new creatures with a focus on higher CR creatures.  There is a heavy focus on creatures from the relevant lore such as devils, demons, drow, and the rest of the races that I mentioned previously. Some of these creatures include epic creatures from the adventures that have been tweaked and fixed to be more in-line with their intended CR.

This book in particular is valuable for DMs especially ones that need some higher CR creatures in their campaigns. However, like VGtMs I’d probably skip out on it if you’re a full-time player.

Dungeon Master’s Guide

It may surprise you that one of the 3 core rule books is so far down my list. Let me explain. The Dungeon Master’s Guide has a ton of content such as variant rules, magical items, and great tips on how to DM. It is not necessary for a player or DM (especially new ones). A lot of the tips and advice given in the book could potentially be found online.

The variant rules are great references but you typically won’t use them all, and there are some very niche or overly specific rules. As you get more comfortable with the game you and your players will probably end up house ruling a lot of the variant rules.

The magical items and treasure are the main draw for me. Especially as a new player or DM you will want to look through the DMG for balance purposes. As a new DM you should stick close to the magic items and treasures in the DMG (and XGtE) for what you reward your players with. This will also serve as a good point of reference for when you create your own items.

There’s a lot of great content in the DMG, but I don’t find it necessary to have in order to run a game for either a DM or a player.

Tier 4 – Fun Extras

The “Fun Extras” books will add some additional fun to a game. They are not referenced often and have a niche use.

Tales from the Yawning Portal

Yawning Portal has been a hit at my table. Art by WotC.

Tales From the Yawning Portal

This is a very fun book for DMs to own. It is what I call a “throwback” book. It contains some of the most iconic D&D adventures from all the different editions but remade for D&D 5e. I recently ran the White Plume Mountain adventure as a one-shot and everyone had a great time. That is both the strength and weakness of this book. The book is a book of one-shots.

There is no continuous story line like with the adventure books. However, you can easily drop one of these adventures or dungeons into a campaign and it will fit right in with minimal tweaking. This is a fun book to have as a DM, or if you are looking for a nostalgia trip for adventures of past editions!

Sword Coast Adventurer’s Guide

The Sword Coast Adventurer’s Guide really suffered from the release of XGtE. This was the first supplementary book that added new character archetypes to 5e. The downside is that there are so few of them to choose from and not every class even has a new archetype. Not to mention that a few of the archetypes and the spells were also reprinted in XGtE! MToF also includes reprints of the duergar and deep gnome subraces which again makes SCAG a less worthwhile purchase.

There is some good lore and setting information on the Sword Coast, but if you aren’t running a game that involves that at all this won’t be a useful book for you. I’d advise you to look up the table of contents of the book and make a judgement call for yourself.

Wayfinder’s Guide to Eberron

There are a few issues I have with this setting book that is making me put it in Tier 4 in its current iteration. First of all, it’s PDF only which is a deal-breaker for many. Second, Wayfinder’s Guide to Eberron is currently playtest material. This means that it is unfinished and will be updated as the book is revised or new content is added to it.

Despite all this Eberron is a very interesting setting as it’s pretty different from the typical high fantasy setting that D&D uses. It is considerably more high-tech as it has robots (warforged), sky ships, and trains that are all magically powered. Morality and alignment is also a very muddled concept in Eberron.

Check out this article for more of a run-down on Eberron.

That being said if Eberron is a setting that your group enjoys this setting book is a must-buy at some point. If you do not mind purchasing unfinished playtest material then this book is probably closer to Tier 3 in the list due to the amount of content it will eventually add to the game.

I’m interested to see what the finished product will look like as it has a ton of potential.

Tier ? – Unreleased Books

Guildmasters’ Guide to Ravnica

D&D 5e book Guildmaster's Guide to Ravnica

An ambitious crossover has just been announced! Art by WotC.

Book Releases on November 20, 2018

The following is speculation and will be updated to reflect a more accurate view when more information is present or when the book is released.

This is a pretty groundbreaking book as it is the first official WotC product to tie Magic: The Gathering into D&D 5e. Ravnica is an enormous city that has a group of 10 guilds that conduct business  and make up the government of Ravnica. Clashes between the guilds is well-known and there some contempt for the guilds by the citizens that choose not to align with the guilds.

There aren’t a lot of specifics known about Guildmasters’ Guide to Ravnica other than it being a setting guide. My speculation is that it will be similar to SCAG in that it is a setting guide and will introduce some new mechanics, races, or class archetypes to D&D 5e.

This book will certainly introduce mechanics for an urban setting and factions which will certainly be welcomed in D&D 5e for those of us that aren’t involved in MTG.

Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage

Book Releases on November 13, 2018

Tier X – Adventures

This is a unique tier. Depending on your group, you may value these more than the books in Tier 3 or 4. Other groups may not have any use for these books at all. The adventures are solid books of varying quality. They provide a customizable story with unique items, creatures, mechanics, maps, and NPCs for you and your friends to enjoy.

Out of the Abyss

Out of the Abyss DnD 5e Book

Out of the Abyss has been my table’s favorite adventure module so far. Art by WotC.

I own a few of the adventures and have used bits and pieces of some throughout my campaigns. My friends and I also played Out of the Abyss and that was so well-received that I’ve used some crowd favorite characters, setting info, and creatures in our other games. If you are looking for a gritty, survival adventure this is an excellent pick-up.

 Curse of Strahd

I have not played or ran Curse of Strahd. However, I have heard great feedback about it from friends and on the internet. If your group is into vampires and gothic horror this is a great adventure to run. The introductory adventure for CoS is available for free online should you wish to “try before you buy”.

Hoard of the Dragon Queen and The Rise of Tiamat

Hoard of the Dragon Queen and The Rise of Tiamat were two of the earliest D&D 5e adventures published. Unfortunately they have suffered a bit due to being early prints. Another strike against them is that the adventure requires the purchase of these two books to be completed. There are a lot of mechanical and story issues with the books. Here’s a reddit thread where people discuss more specific issues with HotDQ. On a positive note, there are at least supplements for HotDQ and RoT that save the DM having to purchase the MM or DMG.

Stom King’s Thunder

Stom King’s Thunder is about giants wrecking havoc on the Sword Coast. I have good things about this adventure. There is a lot of room for the DM to modify the adventure and story. There is interesting lore and rich role-playing hooks as well. The one criticism I have heard about this is that the maps in the Roll20 Version have an issue with scaling.

Tomb of Annihilation

D&D 5e Book Tome of Annihilation

A gritty story filled with necromancy and dinosaurs! Art by WotC.

Tomb of Annihilation is an adventure dealing with death and a mysterious disease. Necromancy is a major theme in this adventure. It is another gritty story, but I have heard tons of praise for its writing. While I can’t personally recommend this adventure, check out this show. Adam Koebel runs the module and it is a well-done play-through.

Princes of the Apocalypse

Princes of the Apocalypse was released early in 5e’s life cycle.  Fortunately, it does not suffer the same fate as HotDQ and RoT! The online supplement warrants some bonus points for PotA as it has all of the monsters and magic items used in the game. The DM could buy just PotA and use the supplement without needing to purchase the MM or DMG. If thwarting evil cults focused around elementals sounds cool, this may be the adventure for you!

Waterdeep: Dragon Heist

Waterdeep: Dragon Heist is an urban adventure book with a heavy focus on role-playing in the city of Waterdeep. The party must establish themselves in Waterdeep and track down a villain that is after a dragon’s hoard. They’ll forge alliances with the different factions in the city and navigate their way through social interactions, bar fights, and the chaos of a city that’s devolving into crime.

At the beginning the campaign the group must choose what season it is in Waterdeep. This will determine which of the 4 villains the party must stop from stealing the treasure. Unlike other adventure books, the party’s goal is simply to stop the villain’s plans and not to kill them.

They’ll have to make good use of their relationships with NPCs, supplies they’ve acquired, and their wit and cunning. The party also gets a home base to use as they please giving them even more resources to use to thwart their villain.

In my opinion this is the best part about W:DH, its replayability. The same group could run through this adventure 4 times and have a completely different story each time. The book is highly regarded as a unique and well-written adventure for groups that enjoy role-playing and planning ahead rather than rushing into a dungeon delve.

The adventure also includes new monsters and magical item, but I wouldn’t call this a selling-point for the book if you’re not looking to run the adventure.

The Starter Set

The starter set is an excellent pickup for a group of first-time players. It includes a small book full of rules and character creation choices for levels 1-5, dice, and an adventure. The Lost Mines of Phandelvr is the adventure, and it is a very well-written, fun, adventure. I have heard nothing but praise for this edition’s starter set and even popular shows such as the The Adventure Zone have used this adventure as a starting point for their campaigns.

Conclusion

Do remember that this is an opinion piece. Feel free to buy whatever books you like.  I will always say to grab the PHB before you look at anything else. I will also be updating this list as new books are added to the D&D 5e book list so feel free to check back later or voice your opinions on my picks!

If this post was helpful for you be sure to check out the rest of my reviews here!

Sign up for e-mail updates and our monthly newsletter using the form below!

2 Comments on “Which D&D 5e Book Should You Buy?

D&Dork
August 25, 2018 at 11:48 pm

pretty good list i can agree with most of it. the PHB is definitely the most important thing ofc. as a full time player i was on the fence on a couple of the books that is currently in my inventory like sword coast tome of foes and volo’s guide, tho i will probably get XGTE soon but will wait till the rest of the base stuff is on sale maybe.

Reply
Eldadres
August 26, 2018 at 1:25 am

Xanathar’s is a blast for sure! Amazon has sales for the books pretty frequently so be sure to keep that on your radar.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Privacy Preference Center

%d bloggers like this: